Home National News Complaint vs. Xi on WPS falls beyond ICC jurisdiction

Complaint vs. Xi on WPS falls beyond ICC jurisdiction

By Joyce Ann L. Rocamora


MANILA — The International Criminal Court (ICC) on Thursday said it has no jurisdiction on the complaint of former Foreign Affairs Secretary Albert del Rosario and former Ombudsman Conchita Carpio Morales alleging that Chinese President Xi Jinping and other Chinese officials have committed crimes against humanity over Beijing’s activities in the South China Sea.

In the report, ICC Prosecutor Fatou Bensouda said that “the crimes allegedly committed do not fall within the territorial or otherwise personal jurisdiction” of the ICC.

Del Rosario, Morales along with other Filipino fishermen in March 2019 accused Xi and some Chinese officials as accountable for crimes against humanity over China’s activities within the Philippines’ exclusive economic zone (EEZ) in the South China Sea and for depriving Filipino fishermen of food and livelihood.

The communication also alleged that China engaged in massive illegal reclamation and artificial island-building in the Spratly Islands as well as tolerated illegal and harmful fishing practices by Chinese nationals in the area, which they claimed not only violated the law of the sea but gave rise to crimes against humanity.

In its report dated December 5, Bensouda’s office pointed out that “China is not a State Party to the Rome Statute. Accordingly, the ICC lacks personal jurisdiction”.

The international court may exercise territorial jurisdiction over the alleged crimes to the extent that they were committed in Philippine territory from November 1, 2011, until March 16, 2019, or before Manila’s withdrawal from the ICC took effect on March 17.

However, it argued that the alleged conduct “occurred in areas that are outside of the Philippines’ territorial sea” or areas farther than 12 nautical miles from its coast, but nonetheless within areas that may be considered to fall within its declared EEZ.

“The Office has concluded that a State’s EEZ (and continental shelf) cannot be considered to comprise part of its ‘territory’ for the purpose of article 12(2)(a) of the Statute,” the ICC Prosecutor said, explaining that the “territory” referred to includes those areas under the sovereignty of the State, namely its landmass, internal waters, territorial sea, and the airspace above such areas.

Meanwhile, it pointed out that the ICC could exercise its jurisdiction if the alleged crime was committed on board vessels registered in a state party to the Rome Statute. This condition, however, is not met, given that the conducts in question were purportedly committed onboard Chinese registered vessels.

“Finally, as previously highlighted, the remaining basis for the exercise jurisdiction (active personality) under article 12(2)(b) is also not met, given the Chinese nationality of the alleged perpetrators in question,” the ICC Prosecutor said.

“Accordingly, the Office concluded that the crimes allegedly committed do not fall within the territorial or otherwise personal jurisdiction of the Court,” it added.

In a joint statement issued a day after the report’s release, del Rosario and Morales vowed to continue pursuing the case. (PNA) 


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

- Advertisment -


Remembering SAF 44

Philippine National Police We proudly salute the gallant SAF 44, our modern-day heroes #SAF44 #PNPKakampiMo

Manila gov’t to distribute face masks amid coronavirus scare

By Ma. Teresa Montemayor   MANILA -- Manila City Mayor Francisco "Isko Moreno" Domagoso on Thursday said the local government will distribute 100,000 face masks to the...

PRRD can still function effectively as President: Panelo

By Ruth Abbey Gita-Carlos   MANILA -- President Rodrigo Duterte, despite his age and health problems, can still “effectively” fulfill his mandate to serve and protect the...

CAB suspends PH-Wuhan flights indefinitely

By Ma. Cristina Arayata   MANILA -- The Civil Aeronautics Board (CAB) on Thursday announced the indefinite suspension of flights between central China’s city of Wuhan and...

Filipino Bags First Prize in 2020 Year of ASEAN Identity Logo Design Competition

JAKARTA 23 January 2020 — A Filipino graphic artist from Lipa, Batangas, Joemari Manguiat, was awarded the first prize in the 2020 Year of...